Louisiana Circuit Courts of Appeal

Louisiana Circuit Courts of Appeal is located in Louisiana
Baton Rouge (1st)
Baton Rouge (1st)
Shreveport (2nd)
Shreveport (2nd)
Lake Charles (3rd)
Lake Charles (3rd)
New Orleans (4th)
New Orleans (4th)
Gretna (5th)
Gretna (5th)
Court locations

The Louisiana Circuit Courts of Appeal are the intermediate appellate courts for the state of Louisiana.

There are five circuits, each covering a different group of parishes.[1] Each circuit is subdivided into three districts.[2]

As with the Louisiana Supreme Court, the regular judicial terms on the courts of appeal are ten years.

The courts of appeal are housed in the following cities in Louisiana:

Jurisdiction

The Circuit Courts of Appeal have appellate jurisdiction over all civil matters, all matters appealed from family and juvenile courts, and most criminal cases that are triable by a jury. A court of appeal also has supervisory jurisdiction to review interlocutory orders and decrees in cases which are heard in the trial courts within their geographical circuits. One unique feature of the Courts of Appeal of Louisiana is that they are able to review questions of fact, as well as questions of law, in civil cases. In appeals of criminal cases, however, the appellate jurisdiction of the courts of appeal extends only to questions of law.[2]

1st Circuit

Parishes Included:

Circuit Seat: First Circuit Courthouse (Baton Rouge)

Current judges[3]
Name Start District Subdistrict Election
Section
Division Party
Vanessa Guidry-Whipple, Chief Judge 1991 1 D Democratic
Mike McDonald 2003 2 1 B Republican
Page McClendon 2002 3 B Republican
Duke Welch 2004 2 1 C Republican
Mitchell Theriot 2012 1 B Republican
Guy Holdridge 2015 1 1 C Republican
Wayne Chutz 2015 3 A Republican
Allison Penzato 2017 3 C Republican
Walter Lanier 2019 1 1 A Republican
Elizabeth Wolfe 2020 3 D Republican
Christopher Hester 2021 2 1 A Republican
Vacant 2025 2 2 D

Vacancies and pending nomination

Vacator Reason Vacancy Date District Subdistrict Election
Section
Division Nominee Nomination Date
John Guidry Elevation January 1, 2025 2 2 D TBD Pending

2nd Circuit

Parishes Included: Bienville, Bossier, Caddo, Caldwell, Claiborne, DeSoto, East Carroll, Franklin, Jackson, Lincoln, Madison, Morehouse, Ouachita, Red River, Richland, Tensas, Union, Webster, West Carroll, Winn

Circuit Seat: Second Circuit Courthouse (Shreveport)

Current judges[4]
Name Start District Election
Section
Division Party
Frances Jones Pitman, Chief Judge 2012 3 2 B Republican
Shonda Stone 2016 3 1 A Democratic
Jeff Cox 2017 2 C Republican
James Stephens 2018 1 2 A Independent
Jeff Thompson 2019 2 2 B Republican
Jeff Robinson 2021 2 1 A Republican
Marcus Hunter 2021 1 1 C Democratic
Craig Marcotte 2022 3 2 C Republican
Danny Ellender 2023 1 2 B Republican

3rd Circuit

Parishes Included: Acadia, Allen, Avoyelles, Beauregard, Calcasieu, Cameron, Catahoula, Concordia, Evangeline, Grant, Iberia, Jefferson Davis, Lafayette, LaSalle, Natchitoches, Rapides, Sabine, St. Landry, St. Martin, Vermilion, Vernon

Circuit Seat: Third Circuit Courthouse (Lake Charles)

Current judges[5]
Name Start District Election
Section
Division Party
Sylvia Cooks, Chief Judge 1992 3 2 D Democratic
Elizabeth Pickett 1997 1 A Independent
Billy Ezell 2003 2 2 B Republican
Shannon Gremillion 2008 1 C Democratic
John Conery 2013 3 3 E Republican
Kent Savoie 2015 2 2 A Republican
Van Kyzar 2017 1 B Democratic
Candyce Perret 2017 1 B Republican
Jonathan Perry 2019 3 4 F Republican
Sharon Wilson 2021 2 1 C Democratic
Charlie Fitzgerald 2021 3 5 A Republican
Gary Ortego 2022 3 3 E Republican

4th Circuit

Parishes Included: Orleans, Plaquemines, St. Bernard

Circuit Seat: Fourth Circuit Courthouse (New Orleans)

Current judges[6]
Name Start District Division Party
Terri Love, Chief Judge 2000 1 E Democratic
Edwin Lombard 2003 1 A Democratic
Roland Belsome 2004 At large Democratic
Daniel Dysart 2010 3 A Independent
Joyce Cossich Lobrano 2010 2 A Republican
Rosemary Ledet 2010 1 G Democratic
Sandra Cabrina Jenkins 2012 1 H Democratic
Paula Brown 2017 1 C Democratic
Tiffany Chase 2017 1 B Democratic
Dale Atkins 2018 1 F Democratic

5th Circuit

Parishes Included: Jefferson, St. Charles, St. James, St. John the Baptist

Circuit Seat: Fifth Circuit Courthouse (Gretna)

Current judges[7]
Name Start Division Party
Susan Chehardy, Chief Judge 1998 D Independent
Fredericka Wicker 2006 B Republican
Jude Gravois 2011 H Democratic
Marc Johnson 2009 C Democratic
Robert Chaisson 2011 I Democratic
Stephen Windhorst 2012 E Republican
Hans Liljeberg 2012 F Republican
John Molaison 2018 G Republican

Judicial misconduct scandal

In May 2007, Jerrold Peterson, staff director for the court, wrote a letter alleging that, starting in 1994, criminal pro se petitions were not being reviewed by a panel of three judges as required by Louisiana law. Instead, every pro se petition received a boilerplate response. At least 5,000 petitions have been disregarded under this policy over a 12 year period. On May 21, 2007, Peterson committed suicide at the age of 55.[8]

References

  1. ^ Map of judicial circuits of the Louisiana Circuit Courts of Appeal
  2. ^ a b Louisiana State Judiciary homepage
  3. ^ "Judges". Louisiana Court of Appeal First Circuit, 22 Nov. 2016. Accessed 2 Apr. 2017.
  4. ^ "Court Personnel Overview". Court of Appeal, Second Circuit State of Louisiana. Accessed 2 Apr. 2017.
  5. ^ "Personnel Directory: Judges". State of Louisiana Third Circuit Court of Appeal. Accessed 2 Apr. 2017.
  6. ^ "Judicial Biography: Active Judges". State of Louisiana Court of Appeal, Fourth Circuit. Accessed 2 Apr. 2017.
  7. ^ "Court Personnel". Fifth Circuit Court of Appeal. Accessed 2 Apr. 2017.
  8. ^ Rubin, Anat (November 4, 2023). "The Scandal That Never Happened". ProPublica. Archived from the original on November 22, 2023. Retrieved November 23, 2023.